Generating Sessions Ids13 Apr 2016
Session Id’s are unique, short-lived numbers that servers assign to users when they log in (or visit) so they can remember (or track) users for the duration of their sessions. Servers use session Id’s to remember users because the underlying protocol, HTTP, is stateless. Once they receive session Id from the server, users send it back in the following requests to identify themselves. For example, when you login to a website, the server assigns you a session Id and sends it to your browser wrapped in a cookie. The browser automatically sends the cookie back in the subsequent requests so the server knows who is making the request.
Almost all web frameworks I have worked with have built-in support for sessions: they generate and assign Id’s under the hood. The only time I had to generate session Id’s manually was when I was building a REST application (game service) that needed a custom way to identify users and sessions. This blog post is the result of research I had to do to build that feature. I would highly recommend not rolling out your custom session handling code, unless you absolutely have to.
Session Ids are unique, transient and non-guessable
Session Id’s must be unique across all users. Can you imagine two people getting assigned the same Social Security number? That would be a disaster.
Session Id’s have ‘best-by’ date and they timeout after a certain period. If they didn’t, a hacker could steal and use them indefinitely. Generally the expiry period ranges from minutes to weeks. High-risk applications expire session Ids more frequently than the low risk ones to minimize the attack window.
Session Id’s are not guessable. A bad example would be an algorithm that generates sequential session Id’s. Hackers can easily identify patterns and hijack user sessions.
You can generate and assign session Id’s to users in many different ways. I’ll discuss three common methods below.
1. Random session Ids
Random session Id’s have no meaning by virtue of being completely random. The server sends them to the client and stores them in a database along with the the user information.
|Session Id||User Id||Expiry Time|
If session Id’s are random numbers, how do we ensure that they cannot be guessed or predicted by hackers? In Cryptography theory, entropy is the measure of uncertainty associated with a random number. Session Id’s should have very high entropy to protect against attacks. OWASP suggests at least 64 bits of entropy. Sounds complex? (it did to me.) The good news is that you and I should never have to worry about writing your own algorithms (Don’t even think about it - random number generation is very complex). Most languages have pseudo random numbers generators (PRNGs) that generate ‘cryptographically secure’ random numbers that have entropy. As an example, Tomcat uses SHA1PRNG to generate a random number and hash it with MD5 (see warning below) to create session Id’s. Here’s a link to the source code (There’s a list of PRNGs for other languages near the end of this post.)
Warning: Do NOT use MD5 to generate session Id’s because it is considered insecure. In the application I was building, I used SHA-2 (SHA-256).
2. Session Id’s using shared secret
These types of session Id’s are created in such a way that the information needed to identify a user is embedded into the session Id itself. Since session Id’s are self-contained, the server doesn’t need to store them. Let’s look at a trivial algorithm that generates session Id’s by combining username, IP address and a client secret:
sessionId = SHA2(username + ipAddress + secretKey /* or salt */)
When a request arrives, it contains the username and IP address is automatically recorded. The server then uses the username, the IP address and secret key to re-generate the session Id and see if it matches with the session Id passed by the client. If it does, the verification is successful.
Note: If you use IP address to calculate session Id’s, keep in mind that the session Id will be invalidated when the IP address changes. This happens very frequently if your users are on a mobile network and are moving. If you are not sure, don’t use the IP address.
The advantage of this method is that the server doesn’t have to maintain state and store session Id’s in a database.
Disclaimer: The Session Id generation formula above is simplistic. Real applications would combine many parameters such as the user’s access group, timestamp, etc. The timestamp is generated based on Session Id’s lifetime to allow it to expire.
Note: There is a cool standard called JSON Web Tokens that allows the payload to carry the information. I haven’t used it but it looks promising.
3. Random session Id’s with a predictable part
This is a slight modification of the Random session Id generation method. The session Id consists of both a random number and a hash combining some properties of the user such as the username and IP address.
sessionId = SHA2(userId + ipAddr) + prngRandomNumber
The resulting session Id is stored in the session store and looked up for each request. I feel this is a little more secure than just using a (Cryptographically secure) random number. Over engineered? May be. But I’ll err on the side of caution.
Before I end this article, let’s briefly discuss security. Because session Id’s are usually portable, as a developer, you need to ensure that they are not easily obtainable by eavesdroppers or can be shared by mistake.
- Don’t send session Id’s unencrypted. Use HTTPS to encrypt all traffic end-to-end.
- Don’t send session Id’s a URL parameter: your users can inadvertently share URL’s thus revealing their session Id. Also, the session Id’s will appear in the web server or application logs and will be visible to anyone who has access to logs.
Here is a small list of cryptographically secure number generators in popular languages:
Update: 3/11/2017 - Removed references to MD5 thanks to HollyGraceful for calling it out.